Carnitas Taco sneak peek

Note: This is the first-ever TedQuarters post that’s not by me. I’m out of town until Thursday, but I’ve enlisted the help of some friends and interesting Internet people to keep the content flowing here while I’m gone. Because this is TedQuarters, they will all be honorary Teds for the sake of their posts. I figured I’d start you out with a Taco Bell post so you didn’t get disoriented. Seth is a reader with access to a Taco Bell test market. He also recently kept a blog about his adventures south of the equator and co-authored an  epic JonahKeri.com post. – Ted

I’m settling into my new home in Berkeley, Calif., and I noticed today that a nearby Taco Bell is selling Cantina Tacos.  Seizing the opportunity to test them out, I swung into the drive through to pick up a carnitas taco and see how they did on this whole pork thing.  I also got two taco supremes (or is it tacos supreme?) with fire sauce, because I wanted to hedge my bets.

Unfortunately, the carnitas didn’t really do it for me.  The taco has a very strong porky flavor, but it seems much more like what a focus group thinks pork is supposed to taste like, as opposed to a real pork flavor.  Nor is it, like Taco Bell beef, its own real thing.  If you can imagine the shredded pork equivalent of bacos, that comes close.  The tortillas were the right level of softness, though a bit thin, and it was served with a lime, which is nice.

I appreciate the risk they took and they effort they made, but it just didn’t do it for me.  While there is a clear distinction between a beef taco and a Taco Bell beef taco — each with its own appropriate circumstances — to me this just tasted like a bad pork taco, as opposed to the Taco Bell styled alternative.  It’s hard to see this replacing a craving for a real pork taco, or anything else for that matter.  Granted, I’m in California, where tacos grow on trees.

3 thoughts on “Carnitas Taco sneak peek

  1. Incidentally, I tried a chicken Cantina Taco for the first time yesterday. It is also not good. TBs attempted move into more authentic Mexican fare is most likely a response to the success that the southwest chain Del Taco has had with their superior, albeit nonsensical ( http://www.aztlan.net/deltacogoof.htm ) Tacos Del Carbon menu items. It’s a pretty poor attempt considering that the Cantina chicken had a pinkish TB sauce slathered all over it.

    I’m really unsure as to why I have even tried either of them given the fact that any taco truck in my adopted city of LA will provide far superior corn tortilla tacos. I guess it has to do with my odd fascination with fast food.

    In sum, TB should stick to what they are good at, which is making ridiculous “Mexican-inspired” food and stay away from trying to manufacture authenticity. It doesn’t work.

  2. I just gave all three cantina tacos a try and all I have to say is thank god I got a volcano burrito also. The steak taco was OK but the other two were below average.

    Comparing Taco Bell’s version of carnitas to that of Chipotle would be like comparing Jeff Francoeur to Vlad Guerrero in his prime. Both have similar traits (bad ball hitters, cannon arms, good pop) but one is just better in every way aside from cost effectiveness. In both cases its worth it to pay more.

Leave a comment