Good riddance to bad rubbish

Pat Burrell retired yesterday, and as Adam Rubin pointed out, he finished his career sixth all time in home runs against the Mets.

What Rubin didn’t point out (but probably knows) is that every other guy on the list besides is either already enshrined in Cooperstown, will be soon, or will render the whole place obsolete with his exclusion.

Burrell, in comparison, looks like just some guy: Undoubtedly a very good Major League hitter but by no means a superstar, a dude whose top baseball-reference comps include Greg Vaughn, Tim Salmon, Ryan Klesko and Danny Tartabull.

He will not be missed.

The following is skewed by the peculiarities of expansion and divisional play, I realize. List via Rubin’s post. Mays gets the asterisk because I didn’t count the home runs he hit with the Mets as part of his career total:

Guy HR vs. Mets % of career HR
Willie Stargell 60 12.6
Mike Schmidt 49 8.9
Chipper Jones 48 10.6
Willie McCovey 48 9.2
Hank Aaron 45 6
Pat Burrell 42 14.4
Willie Mays 39 6*
Barry Bonds 38 5
Andre Dawson 36 8.2
Billy Williams 34 8

Leave a comment