Is TedQuarters True SABR?

Today my sabermetric writing lies behind me rather than ahead, and I think I am about ready to say, “Farewell to Stats.”

For a whole generation of fans and fantasy players, stats have begun to outstrip story and that seems to me a sad thing. Even the unverifiable hogwash that passed for fact or informed opinion in baseball circles not so long ago seems today wistfully enticing, for its energy if nothing else.

John Thorn, MLB Official Historian.

I don’t get it. Why does understanding the way we quantify baseball necessarily strip the sport of its good stories? I’ll amount that I find a good deal (but certainly not all) of the extremely stat-heavy baseball writing boring. But it seems lazy, to me, to turn to “unverifiable hogwash” just because it makes for a more enjoyable story.

I generally avoid mission statements, but on this site I try to write about the things that actually happen and matter in baseball, and present them in an entertaining fashion. It is a challenge and I don’t always succeed, I know. But I would rather strive for that ideal and fail — knowing that at the very least I’m not filling readers’ heads up with fallacious nonsense — than write pretty, fluffy stories attached to nothing substantive.

Is this a sabermetric blog? I’ve never called it that, but I’ve been accused of it on Twitter for sure. And I don’t really care one way or the other, because I’m not even sure what that means. The baseball writing on this site is informed by the way I watch baseball, which is in turn informed by the stats I sometimes look up on the Internet.

 

Polls: Not a good way to determine anything

Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter was voted the greatest New York athlete ever, with Babe Ruth coming in a close second, according to a poll released Tuesday.

Jeter — a five-time World Series champion — earned 14 percent of the vote, while 11 percent tipped their hats to Ruth, according to the poll conducted by the Siena College Research Institute.

Joe DiMaggio, Mickey Mantle and former Jets quarterback Joe Namath rounded out the top five.

Clemente Lisi, N.Y. Post.

This might be a fun topic for debate if Babe Ruth didn’t do the bulk of his damage in New York. Ruth is the best baseball player ever. His stats are so sexy, his baseball-reference page is blocked by SNY’s web filter. He played in seven World Series with the Yankees and won four of them. Even though he converted to being a full-time position player before coming to New York, he randomly pitched in five games in his Yankee career and got the win in all of them.

The more interesting argument is over the second-best New York athlete of all time. Here the case for Jeter could be made, I suppose, since he plays a premium position, is the Yankees’ all-time hit leader, and has the five rings and all. But I think it’s tough to even call him the second-best Yankee; that distinction should probably go to Mickey Mantle.

Who else, though? I’d love to put a Met in the discussion but, as good as Tom Seaver was, he probably didn’t contribute as much to the Mets all told as Mantle did to the Yankees. Lawrence Taylor? I could make that case. Patrick Ewing? Mike Tyson before 1990?

What killed the spitball?

Is there a connection in the game today to Frank Shellenback? Yes there is! The most notable connection is Phil Regan, who had a fairly good spitball. Regan went on to become a manager, coach and pitching coach, including coaching on the 2000 U.S. Olympic baseball team, with pitchers Ryan Franklin, Roy Oswalt, Bobby Seay and Ben Sheets*.

* Tin foil hat time, folks.

In many ways we can point the rise and fall of the spitball to one person: Frank Shellenback, the Sinister Minister of the Spitball.

Mat Kovach, The Hardball Times.

A good read from The Hardball Times about the history of the Major Leagues’ most reviled pitch. Kovach credits the resurgence of the spitball to Frank Shellenback, and — though he doesn’t say it outright — seems to suggest that as Shellenback’s legacy wanes, so does the spitball.

I wonder if spitballs, vaseline balls, snotballs, scuffed balls and doctored balls of all varieties are quickly becoming a thing of the past thanks to modern technology. It seems like with the number of HD cameras in stadiums now, a pitcher would need to be David Blaine to get away with it with any regularity. Of course, I guess some subtle sandpaper in the glove could still go unnoticed.

The Extra 2%

In sizing up the possibility of inking Longoria to a multi-year contract, Friedman seized on the practices he developed in his private equity days. When investing in a company, he had to assess not only that firm’s operations but also the quality and risk tolerance of management, the current trends within its industry, and the state of the broader economy. Likewise with a potential Longoria deal, Friedman had to consider a lot more than the quality of the player. The success of the Crawford contract and similar deals across baseball offered a sound precedent. The Rays’ revenue streams—outside of the estimated $70 million to $80 million a year they would pocket in revenue shared via MLB Advanced Media and other league-wide ventures, as well as from richer teams—remained tight. And then there was the matter of Longoria’s agent.

Paul Cohen, an agent for Los Angeles-based TWC Sports whose client list included Yankees second baseman Robinson Cano, Braves pitcher Tim Hudson, and Rockies shortstop Troy Tulowitzki, also repped Tulowitzki’s former Long Beach State teammate Longoria. After tearing up Double A for most of the 2007 season, Longoria’s numbers tailed off slightly in Triple A as he hit .269/.398/.490 with 29 strikeouts in 31 games. Cohen had just locked down a six-year, $31 million contract for Tulowitzki—the biggest contract of all time for a player with one-plus seasons of major league service time—with a $15 million club option at the end. Would his other high-profile Long Beach State Dirtbag client, Baseball America’s number-two prospect for 2008, be willing to consider an even longer deal, coming off zero seasons of service time?

Jonah Keri, the Extra 2%. Via GQ.

GQ magazine presents an excerpt from Keri’s new book, which hits shelves today. It charts the way the Rays’ front office used Wall Street techniques to build a winner, and seems likely to become a must-read for baseball nerds. This excerpt lacks a heavy-handed locksmith analogy though.

Dawn of the chicken and waffle sandwich

Our man Toby Hyde passes along this link. Darren Rovell at CNBC.com is asking readers to vote for concepts for the “Best New Ballpark Food.” The Savannah Sand Gnats will serve the winner. TedQuarters is excited to hereby endorse the chicken and waffle sandwich — with waffles as buns. Please go vote for it, and then I’ll figure out when I can get to Savannah this season.